Safety note: Admin approval is an initial review, not a guarantee that every detail is correct. Check important or urgent claims with official sources and report anything inaccurate or unsafe.
Source and credit: Contributor's own report
Melbourne Public Housing Residents Take Tower Demolition Fight to High Court - Melbourne, VIC
Smart summary
Residents affected by Victoria’s plan to demolish 44 public housing towers are challenging the decision in Australia’s highest court, arguing they were not properly consulted before their homes were targeted for redev...
A major legal dispute over Melbourne’s public housing towers is moving closer to a decisive stage, with residents challenging the Victorian Government’s plan to progressively demolish and redevelop 44 public housing towers across Melbourne. The issue is receiving renewed attention today, 5 October 2026, ahead of the High Court hearing scheduled for this week.
The Victorian Government announced the redevelopment program in 2023, saying the older high-rise towers had reached the end of their useful lives and needed to be replaced with modern, accessible housing. The government plans to redevelop the sites progressively through to 2051.
At the time the redevelopment program was announced, around 10,000 people were living across the 44 towers. The government says the redevelopment will ultimately provide more homes and improve the quality, accessibility and safety of public and social housing.
However, some residents have strongly opposed the plan and argue they should have been consulted before the decision to demolish their homes was made.
The legal challenge focuses on whether residents had a legally recognised interest that required the government to provide them with procedural fairness before deciding to demolish the towers. The case, Saleh v Homes Victoria, has reached the High Court after the Victorian Court of Appeal previously ruled that the demolition decision was not subject to an obligation to provide procedural fairness to residents.
The High Court case is scheduled for a full-court hearing in Canberra on 7 October 2026. The legal question is significant because the outcome could affect how governments make major decisions involving public housing residents and redevelopment projects.
Residents involved in the campaign say they were informed about the demolition plans after the government had already made the decision. Some residents have described their homes as more than simply buildings, arguing that long-term neighbours and community networks provide important social support.
One resident, Lyrae Fiddes, lives in a tower included in the redevelopment program and has described the announcement as a major shock for residents. She and other residents have argued that the government should have consulted communities before deciding that their homes would be demolished.
The dispute has also attracted international attention. A UN housing expert raised concerns about the redevelopment program and called for further consideration of the human-rights implications. The Victorian Government has rejected calls to stop the redevelopment and says it believes the existing towers do not provide adequate modern housing.
Victoria’s government says it is supporting residents through relocation, including assistance designed to help households move to alternative accommodation. Homes Victoria maintains that the redevelopment program will deliver new and improved homes and says residents will continue to receive support during the process.
The Victorian Ombudsman is also investigating the experiences of residents affected by the tower demolitions and relocations. Its investigation includes questions about whether replacement homes are suitable, how residents are supported when moving and how the government communicates with people affected by the redevelopment.
The High Court proceedings could therefore become an important moment in the long-running dispute. While the court will focus on the legal question of procedural fairness, the wider disagreement concerns housing security, community connections, redevelopment and the future of public housing in Melbourne.
For residents, the case represents an attempt to challenge how the demolition decisions were made. For the Victorian Government, the redevelopment remains a major housing project intended to replace ageing towers with newer homes.
The legal proceedings are continuing, and the High Court has not yet delivered a final decision on the residents’ challenge.
ResidentsGovernmentHousingRedevelopmentHomes
A major legal dispute over Melbourne’s public housing towers is moving closer to a decisive stage, with residents challenging the Victorian Government’s plan to progressively demolish and redevelop 44 public housing towers across Melbourne. The issue is receiving renewed attention today, 5 October 2026, ahead of the High Court hearing scheduled for this week.
The Victorian Government announced the redevelopment program in 2023, saying the older high-rise towers had reached the end of their useful lives and needed to be replaced with modern, accessible housing. The government plans to redevelop the sites progressively through to 2051.
At the time the redevelopment program was announced, around 10,000 people were living across the 44 towers. The government says the redevelopment will ultimately provide more homes and improve the quality, accessibility and safety of public and social housing.
However, some residents have strongly opposed the plan and argue they should have been consulted before the decision to demolish their homes was made.
The legal challenge focuses on whether residents had a legally recognised interest that required the government to provide them with procedural fairness before deciding to demolish the towers. The case, Saleh v Homes Victoria, has reached the High Court after the Victorian Court of Appeal previously ruled that the demolition decision was not subject to an obligation to provide procedural fairness to residents.
The High Court case is scheduled for a full-court hearing in Canberra on 7 October 2026. The legal question is significant because the outcome could affect how governments make major decisions involving public housing residents and redevelopment projects.
Residents involved in the campaign say they were informed about the demolition plans after the government had already made the decision. Some residents have described their homes as more than simply buildings, arguing that long-term neighbours and community networks provide important social support.
One resident, Lyrae Fiddes, lives in a tower included in the redevelopment program and has described the announcement as a major shock for residents. She and other residents have argued that the government should have consulted communities before deciding that their homes would be demolished.
The dispute has also attracted international attention. A UN housing expert raised concerns about the redevelopment program and called for further consideration of the human-rights implications. The Victorian Government has rejected calls to stop the redevelopment and says it believes the existing towers do not provide adequate modern housing.
Victoria’s government says it is supporting residents through relocation, including assistance designed to help households move to alternative accommodation. Homes Victoria maintains that the redevelopment program will deliver new and improved homes and says residents will continue to receive support during the process.
The Victorian Ombudsman is also investigating the experiences of residents affected by the tower demolitions and relocations. Its investigation includes questions about whether replacement homes are suitable, how residents are supported when moving and how the government communicates with people affected by the redevelopment.
The High Court proceedings could therefore become an important moment in the long-running dispute. While the court will focus on the legal question of procedural fairness, the wider disagreement concerns housing security, community connections, redevelopment and the future of public housing in Melbourne.
For residents, the case represents an attempt to challenge how the demolition decisions were made. For the Victorian Government, the redevelopment remains a major housing project intended to replace ageing towers with newer homes.
The legal proceedings are continuing, and the High Court has not yet delivered a final decision on the residents’ challenge.
The Tasmanian Government has begun approaching potential financial partners as concerns grow over the rising cost of the proposed Macquarie Point stadiu...
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is meeting Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr in Manila following a new defence cooperation agreement focused on m...
Public school teachers in the Australian Capital Territory have rejected another government offer, keeping concerns over classroom arrangements and teac...
Independent federal MP Helen Haines has begun rehabilitation after being discharged from a Melbourne hospital, weeks after a vehicle attack outside her...
Victorian detectives have arrested a teenager following an investigation into alleged organised crime attacks targeting bars, clubs and restaurants acro...
Police are investigating a daylight theft after three valuable trophies belonging to Australia's legendary racehorse were taken from an exhibition displ...
A digital examination platform failure disrupted final assessments in Melbourne, leaving hundreds of students unable to access their exams and forcing u...
A front-seat passenger died at the scene after a vehicle left the road and struck a tree in western Victoria, while the driver suffered life-threatening...
Victorian detectives have arrested a teenager following an investigation into alleged organised crime attacks targeting bars, clubs and restaurants acro...
South Australian police have arrested a man and a woman after allegedly discovering 910 alkaloid poppy plants growing at a residential property in Brahm...
A 15-year-old boy has been left in critical condition after being shot with an arrow in Kempsey, while police investigate reports involving people alleg...
Two teenage boys have suffered stab wounds during a violent confrontation at Castle Towers Shopping Centre in Sydney's north-west, prompting an emergenc...